comparison-shop

Best pizza nyc: the top 10

Ranked by how many of the 7 lists include each pick.

  1. 1

    Joe's Pizza

    On 4 of 7 lists

    A Greenwich Village pizzeria serving classic New York slices since 1975, with thin, crispy crust and tangy sauce, and multiple locations with late hours. The slices are big, floppy, foldable and glistening.

  2. 2

    John's of Bleecker Street

    Visit
    On 4 of 7 lists

    A 1929 West Village institution serving very thin coal-oven pies sold whole in a sit-down, kid-friendly setting. Its sauce is phenomenal and the room has an upscale feel.

  3. 3

    Mama's Too

    On 4 of 7 lists

    Mama's Too is a tiny Upper West Side slice shop known for thick, heavily topped square slices, airy Roman dough that crisps like a cookie, and standout pies such as the Angry Nonna and poached pear. It also serves sandwiches and homemade gelato.

  4. 4

    Emmy Squared

    On 3 of 7 lists

    Emmy Squared serves Detroit-style pizza with crispy, cheesy edges, including Classic, Vodka, and MVP pies that travel well for takeout. It has locations in the West Village and Williamsburg and feels a bit commercial.

  5. 5

    L'Industrie Pizzeria

    On 3 of 7 lists

    Williamsburg slice shop combining New York-style structure with high-quality Italian ingredients and toppings applied to order. The Burrata slice and pistachio soft serve stand out; the wait can run an hour.

  6. 6

    Scarr's Pizza

    Visit
    On 3 of 7 lists

    A Lower East Side pizzeria known for its crust and iconic hot honey, opened by childhood friends as a tribute to the pizza of their youth. Lines and crowds persist, so avoiding peak meal times helps.

  7. 7

    Williamsburg Pizza

    On 3 of 7 lists

    Fronted by award-winning pizzaiolo Nino Coniglio, it serves true New York-style slices with crunchy crusts and chewy interiors, and the thick, buttery Grandma pies are the pick.

  8. 8

    Ace's Pizza Spot

    On 2 of 7 lists

    A Williamsburg spot serving Detroit-style square pizza, with the Hot Burrata pie a go-to order. The hole-in-the-wall space also has video games.

  9. 9

    Chrissy's Pizza

    On 2 of 7 lists

    Classic New York-style pies made with better ingredients and obsessive detail in Greenpoint. The shop is tiny and serves no slices.

  10. 10

    Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern

    Visit
    On 2 of 7 lists

    Staten Island's most famous pizzeria, serving pizza since 1951 and drawing legions of fans, with a nearly-as-good Greenwich Village outpost. The clam pie is the exciting order.

Add a list we missed

Paste a link to another "best of" list and we'll merge its picks into this ranking. Only you see the result.

Lists we read

Where this ranking comes from, including pages we couldn't read.

Sites that block our reader can still be added from your own browser with the Chrome extension.

Who recommends what

A number is the pick's rank on that list. means recommended without a rank.

Pickscottspizzatours.comny.eater.comcntraveler.comdishelinguide.comthe-carboholic.comfoodieflashpacker.comatly.comLists
1. Joe's PizzaRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedRecommendedNot mentionedRecommendedNot mentioned4
2. John's of Bleecker StreetRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedRecommendedNot mentionedRecommendedNot mentioned4
3. Mama's TooRecommendedRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentioned4
4. Emmy SquaredRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentionedRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentioned3
5. L'Industrie PizzeriaRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentionedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentioned3
6. Scarr's PizzaRecommendedRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentioned3
7. Williamsburg PizzaRecommendedNot mentionedRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentioned3
8. Ace's Pizza SpotRecommendedNot mentionedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentioned2
9. Chrissy's PizzaRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentioned2
10. Denino's Pizzeria & TavernRecommendedRecommendedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentionedNot mentioned2