Skip the ten tabs.
Shopping for the best of anything means opening every review list and keeping score yourself. We read about ten of them for you and stack up the picks they agree on.
L'Industrie Pizzeria
- The Carboholic
- Eater NY
- Atly
- Scotts Pizza Tours
- GlobetrotterGirls
- The Infatuation
- Anders & Kaitlin
- Foodie Flashpacker left it off
- Condé Nast Traveler left it off
- The Dishelin Guide left it off
10 reviewers vote on best pizza nyc
Found 10 lists
Pick a list to see where its counters went.
- The Carboholic
- Foodie Flashpacker
- Eater NY
- Atly
- Condé Nast Traveler
- Scotts Pizza Tours
- GlobetrotterGirls
- The Dishelin Guide
- The Infatuation
- Anders & Kaitlin
- 1L'Industrie PizzeriaOn 7 of 10 lists
- 2Joe's PizzaOn 6 of 10 lists
- 3Mama's TooOn 6 of 10 lists
- 4Scarr's PizzaOn 5 of 10 lists
- 5Di Fara PizzaOn 4 of 10 lists
- 6F&F PizzeriaOn 4 of 10 lists
- 7John's of Bleecker StreetOn 4 of 10 lists
- 8OpsOn 4 of 10 lists
What we do
The rules 3 moves
You type what you're shopping for
A skillet, a robot vacuum, a pizza place, a sci-fi book. Anything people write "best of" lists about.
We read the lists
We find about ten review lists, read each one, and pull out every pick it recommends.
You get one ranking
We rank every pick by how many lists recommend it. Each item names the list it came from, so you can check the source.
What's free
- Searches anyone has run before. Open them as often as you like. No account needed.
- One new search, or five if you sign in. Signing in is free.
- After five searches, 1 credit per search. 50 credits cost $5 and never expire.
That's all the fine print.

